News Home Exclusives Celebrity Music Movie TV Videos
Slideshows Hot or Not? TV Recaps Fashion Interviews Celeb Birthdays

'American Idol' Recap: Awful Song Choices, Bad Performances & A Beatles Desecration

May 6th, 2009 8:51am EDT Post a comment

Now it's time to get serious. We are in the final four of American Idol, meaning it is time to do away with the sophomoric ramblings as we wait for the show to begin.

Read more!

21 Member Comments

Page down to comment | Original Story

Wed May 6 2009 09:15:27 By: Layla02062 (

200)
I thought Adam's performance rocked and his duet with Allison was tremendous. I really liked the Kris and Danny duet. I think Kris will go home tonight. I liked his song choice but he did a poor job of singing it; he did not work the stage as a rock star would have done (and he was advised to do).

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 10:01:02 By: PhDude (

3)
This review is crap and the reviewer is a delusional homophobe. I have read about 50 reviews this morning and this is the only one where the author pretends that Adam was not AMAZING last night and did not blow the rest of the competition away.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 10:01:17 By: PhDude (

3)
Adam was AMAZING last night! Not only was he amazing he answered his critics, with the help of Gokey, and showed us the difference between screaming and singing. Everybody can now stop saying that Adam screams... If you want to know what a scream sounds like just listen to Danny killing (and I mean that in a bad murdering chalk outline kind of way) the poor innocent song Dream On. That is screaming. You know it. It was bad. Yuck. My ears were bleeding. His fans know it too. I am sorry but there is a difference between screaming and Rock N Roll. We saw that difference last night. Vote for the Worst pick Danny Gokey = screaming. Adam Lambert = Rock N Roll.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 10:41:28 By: Mrs Danger (

8)
I think they did great last night especially Adam i love him but i think that the top two will be Adam and Allison who will be the winner idk but they both are awesome and i love them and their duet was UNBELIEVEABLE. I loved it soooooo much.
Jessica.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 10:41:51 By: stachia13 (

6)
I thought that Adam and Allison kicked major butt last night.... Hope they both make it into the top two!

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 11:48:05 By: colton rocks (

2)
u rock Adam Lambert love yea u shuld win

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 12:24:58 By: bluman (

428)
adam is easily the best of the bunch

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 12:28:57 By: balmod (

1)
danny should leave

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 12:29:42 By: Tom Sizemore (

18677)
I took some unneccessary words out of the title and shortened it:
'American Idol': Awful

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 14:13:41 By: 666_Steinbrener (

980)
Don't watch this show but just gave a listen to a few on youtube. Adam Lambert sounds like Mariah Carey singing Zep. Just craptacular. Rock is raw and not diva drama sounding.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 14:49:47 By: TV Addict (

1406)
Counting down the days until this show is over. Stick a fork in it.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 16:34:36 By: geeneebee (

1)
Adam has it all - like Elvis!

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:18:24 By: charm 1969 (

6)
Hated your recap of last nights show. Your a terrible critic.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:19:24 By: charm 1969 (

6)
Only one that should go home to night is Danny. He messed up big time. I thought all the others were great. Just keepin it real ppl

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:21:26 By: charm 1969 (

6)
I think I agree with PHDude 100 percent!

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:21:49 By: charm 1969 (

6)
Hope your not getting paid to be a critic.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:23:28 By: charm 1969 (

6)
counting down the days till the show is over? well it can be over you any time dude, just dont watch it or visit these sites. Stupid

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 17:24:33 By: charm 1969 (

6)
well now that I made my comments I wont be reading his stuff any longer, hes crapola.

[Report]

Wed May 6 2009 19:40:11 By: nicerack (

8973)
never watched it.

[Report]

Thu May 7 2009 07:58:37 By: wwFang (

97)
Don't know why but i really don't like Adam.And Kris is the BEST!

[Report]

Fri May 8 2009 19:06:30 By: priscilla1 (

2)
Allison should NOT have gone home. Chris is sweet (and beat her out with the public's votes) but Allison has more talent - - and should have stayed in the game, period!

[Report]