News Home Exclusives Celebrity Music Movie TV Videos
Slideshows Hot or Not? TV Recaps Fashion Interviews Celeb Birthdays

Megan Eliminated On 'American Idol' - Thoughts?

April 2nd, 2009 8:43am EDT Post a comment

Why write a coherent recap of American Idol when we can ramble? If they don't want to produce a watchable show, why should I produce a readable column?

Read more!

14 Member Comments

Page down to comment | Original Story

Thu Apr 2 2009 11:10:40 By: Breannaloveskristen (

1)
i think anoop will go home next week..
adam will win it for sure.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 11:12:21 By: cat27 (

1967)
No thoughts.
None.
Idol was awesome now it just kinda........not.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 11:23:17 By: geoffy-weffys_gurl (

9)
I dont like american idol anymore.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 12:12:23 By: lolav (

813)
I think Megan was under-appreciated. I sensed some relief in her when she was voted off. It is rough having a two-year old child and being away from him for so long. Who will go next? Anoop, Scott, or Matt. One is only as good as one's last performance. I agree with stevebody that this article had quite the superior tone. I loved Lady Gaga and David Cook's performances. I think this writer is being paid to be snide.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 12:51:20 By: Andrew Payne (

12)
@stevebody - Some excellent venom you're spewing there. I like your gusto. Not sure where in my comments everybody is getting that I don't like 'American Idol'. I like the shows where something actually happens, and not the results shows where they try to stretch 30 minutes of content into a full hour. I mean they seriously took ten minutes to have each contestant walk to the middle of the stage for ostensibly no reason other than to kill time. And nobody actually likes those Ford commercials, I'm sorry, music videos right?
Also, @lolav - Did I not call Lady Gaga's performance incredibly entertaining? That doesn't qualify as praise? It's just that her songs have lyrics that guy in a middle school creative writing class would think were too lame.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 13:13:09 By: Charcon152 (

6)
I think that Megan should have went home. She was a little flippant with Simon, and it got her on a journey home. I feel that Matt has to step his game back up and do what has got him through and what got him good praise from the judges. The judges has Adam thinking that he is soooooo good, whit his theater experience that he could win. If Lil gets back to what got her through with songs by Mary J. that she could pull off getting to the final four, but she has no room for error. And the judges were to hard and rude to her. They don't have to be so blank rude to get their point across.

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 14:48:19 By: baby ruth (

12)
i like them shoes but you cant sing holla

[Report]

Thu Apr 2 2009 16:14:27 By: 666_Steinbrener (

980)
Stevebody... you forgot end with "get off my lawn"

[Report]

Fri Apr 3 2009 11:26:34 By: Tris451 (

320)
I think we will see more of Megan. She is ultra-cool and original. I don't know what the fuss over Lil Rounds is all about. She seems ordinary to me. Unless he pulls off the performance of a lifetime next week, Anoop (I fear) will be next.

[Report]

Fri Apr 3 2009 23:25:08 By: old observer (

1)
The present method of voting is ridiculous.It has only worked 3 times.One year the person voted off early{kelly}was the only real winner.I don't think Megan would have have won but for entertainment value she had a lot more to offer than at least 4 of the others.! ph.no.1 vote would make it a much more accurate result. won't watch it now as there isn't enough talent to make it worth wasting an hour,and have to put up with that Elvis wsnnabee that everyone raves about,he ain't even close.

[Report]

Sat Apr 4 2009 01:02:18 By: beyoncefan01 (

84)
I really think that Anoop should be eliminated next.I always watch AI on TV via satellite and when I watch him,he's got a great voice but I think he's boring.I wish Megan would've stayed!Who I want to win is Danny,Adam,or Scott.Oops!I forgot Kris.He's great.

[Report]

Sat Apr 4 2009 06:59:43 By: Parton781 (

300)
I think we will see more of Megan.

[Report]

Sat Apr 4 2009 17:31:53 By: cat27 (

1967)
Megan= spastic seagull.
What a moron. As if her singing wasn't enough humiliation for her.

[Report]

Sat Apr 4 2009 17:37:39 By: cat27 (

1967)
I'm with you Grim.....even if just in spirit. Lol.
Girl is a loony bird.

[Report]