News Home Exclusives Celebrity Music Movie TV Videos
Slideshows Hot or Not? TV Recaps Fashion Interviews Celeb Birthdays

Music Video Battle: Beyonce vs. Mariah Carey

November 3rd, 2008 4:18pm EST Post a comment

Mariah Carey and Beyonce Knowles, two of the hottest female music stars, both have new black & white music videos. Watch them here and tell us who YOU think made the better video by leaving a comment below!

Read more!

24 Member Comments

Page down to comment | Original Story

Mon Nov 3 2008 17:20:27 By: betncy (

2)
mariah! She definely got it right

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 17:29:27 By: Danielle0345 (

276)
I think Beyonce video is better, and plus, Beyonce look way better than Mariah Carey.

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 18:50:20 By: NormaNavarro (

1)
Both of these ladies are awesome! I really cannot decide, as far as the topic matter of the songs, I think women all over the world can relate to both videos.

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 19:06:54 By: PureSexyness2009 (

407)
beyonce all the way

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 19:24:17 By: Tionna (

1)
I am a fan of both Beyonce & Mariah, so I'll have to say both videos is good.

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 19:28:46 By: melg (

147)
Neither one is very hot.Mariah's video is a better video.

[Report]

Mon Nov 3 2008 21:18:02 By: hernalyn (

48)
mariah and beyonce are both great..

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 00:37:34 By: FaithNMe (

111)
Love both of them but I love MC more!

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 07:05:44 By: mlowens (

22)
beyonce video is great! mariah need to step it up a bit more.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 08:08:36 By: Felix Lassiter (

3313)
Ha Ha Phonies right down to their school bus yellow toenail's.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 09:19:10 By: nylnel53 (

5)
Both are very talented entertainers. I could watch both over and over. Keep doing what your doing ladies. The results are outstanding. Stay happy and creative.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 12:33:07 By: Lendor (

51)
Beyonce Knowles what's she's doing at all times. She stays true to herself.
Mariah is too into herself.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 14:01:29 By: CARAMEL DELIGHT (

39)
IMA JUS LEAVE IT LIKE THIS I DONT LIKE BEYONCE BECAUSE SHE THINKS SHE IS ALL THAT....AND I THINK THAT MARIAH CANNON IS GOING TO WIN THIS VIDEO.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 15:02:51 By: myviewforonce (

2)
Mariah and Beyonce are both talented young ladies. Yes, we know but one can really sing (Mariah) and one can really dance (Beyonce). So... really there should not be a competition.

[Report]

Tue Nov 4 2008 22:59:23 By: danigga (

2)
well i think that beyonce would beat mariah but thats just my comment but i like mariah i love her song and sometimes beyonce got some weird song but she got some really good songs but yeah thats my comment??peace

[Report]

Wed Nov 5 2008 09:01:43 By: RASHARPE (

755)
DOES IT REALLY MATTER ?

[Report]

Wed Nov 5 2008 22:51:16 By: SLIPKNOT6606 (

6)
I like Mariah's old songs better,I have never really been a huge Beyonce fan but this is the only song I really like.so am going with Beyonce!

[Report]

Thu Nov 6 2008 14:17:42 By: Johnsangel (

2094)
Beyonce!

[Report]

Fri Nov 7 2008 02:49:19 By: bluelagoon (

494)
Who really cares, they are both amazing talents.
They are both successful beautiful strong women!
I guess I do care! LOL...

[Report]

Fri Nov 7 2008 18:18:44 By: LYNDAB (

11)
THEY BOTH SUCK!

[Report]

Tue Nov 11 2008 08:08:30 By: dew2poppin23 (

14)
beyonce has nothing on mariyah carey....but dey both is nice

[Report]

Thu Nov 13 2008 10:04:28 By: codyrhodesismyluv (

22)
Dis 1 iz hard . Iay TIE OR BEYONCE.

[Report]

Thu Dec 11 2008 15:27:22 By: ttgraves_09 (

1)
i most definetly say beyonce's black and white video was hella better then mariah's because everytime she have a new video the less clothes she wear. beyonce hella mo better

[Report]

Tue Dec 1 2009 18:53:48 By: youngest in charge (

2)
well i love both of them they both sing well and r both beautiful so i say both dhatt!

[Report]