There was also no love for new American Idol judge Kara Dioguardi (14) either, as the big brown eyed beauty was voted off by #3 Carmen Electra, ruining our upset predictions. Upsets in the first round included #13 Alyssa Milano defeating Girls Next Door beauty Kendra Wilkinson (4); and Dollhouse star Eliza Dushku (13) taking out socialite Kim Kardashian (4). The largest margin of defeat though was between a couple of 8 & 9 seeds, with Kristen Bell handily defeating another Girl Next Door, Bridget Marquardt, 80-20.