Chris Evans - Captain America. Tens of comic book fans cried, "You can't be two characters in the same universe! Stop ruining my immersion!" Sure, Evans was the Human Torch in FOX's original Fantastic Four, but that shouldn't bar him from coming back to Marvel when they offer him the most patriotic role. There were also questions whether Evans could play Cap in a stoic manner, as many fans were used to his bombastic turns in Fantastic Four and Scott Pilgrim vs. the World.